Copyright 2011-2023 School of Public Policy and Management of Tsinghua University All Rights Reserved Tel: (86)10-62773832 Fax: (86)10-62782853 Email: [email protected]
- Published: 22 July 2011
A world-class university in China? The case of Tsinghua
- Rui Yang 1 &
- Anthony Welch 2
Higher Education volume 63 , pages 645–666 ( 2012 ) Cite this article
Higher education, an integral part of China’s nation-building project, is a critical element in China’s strategic policy initiative of building national strength through science and education. One way to achieve this goal is to develop a higher education system of international stature. Perhaps more than any other country, through national programs such as 211 and 985, China has been explicit in selecting its best universities for intensive investment, with the expressed aim of making them world-class within coming decades, and contributing more to overall R&D and scientific development. Analysing how these top-tier universities in China are reaching for the gold standard, and using Tsinghua University as an example, this article examines the role of higher education in China’s rise and how Chinese universities are responding to the drive for innovation, against a background of globalisation and internationalisation. It analyses the experience of Tsinghua, a Chinese flagship university, sometimes dubbed ‘China’s MIT’, through an in-depth case study in an international context, seeking to answer the question of how far Tinsghua embodies the qualities of a world-class university.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution .
Buy single article.
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT (Russian Federation)
Rent this article via DeepDyve.
Notwithstanding the fact that in the latest international league tables, Peking and Tsinghua (ranked respectively 37 and 58 in the 2010–2011 THES World University Rankings) have each improved significantly, and now outrank several other well-known institutions, while the president of Moscow University also recently referred to Peking University as a world-class institution. As of 2010, at least according to one ranking system, China had 3 universities in the top 100 universities worldwide. As seen in the following diagram, in comparison with the US (54) or even the UK (14), this might seem a modest total, yet it should be noted that the other regional giant, India, is not found among the top 100 at all; indeed, other than China, no other developing country is found among the top 100. Even among wealthy, developed OECD countries such as Australia (5), Canada (4) Germany (3) France (3) and Japan (2), a modest set of universities number among the top 100, despite a decades or centuries long head-start on China (Global Higher Education 2010 ). This demonstrates the Chinese dubious attitude towards the use of mixed objective and subjective indicators by the THE index. It explains why Peking University has remained low-key on its high position in the THE rankings.
The C9 League is an association of China’s nine leading universities including Fudan, Harbin Institute of Technology, Nanjing, Peking, Shanghai Jiao Tong, Tsinghua, University of Science and Technology of China, Xi’an Jiao Tong and Zhejiang. They were the first to be selected for Project 985. On 12 October 2009 they signed cooperative agreements that featured flexible student exchange programs, deepened cooperation on the training of postgraduates, and establishment of a credit system that allows students to win credits through attending classes in member universities. However, it has merely been a formality.
For instance, although ranked 2 nationwide, Tsinghua only produced 56 SSCI publications in 2008 (Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China 2009 ). Such disciplinary differentiation is basically due to the varied ideologies, paradigms and discourses inherent in the humanities and social sciences and the high dependency on language to convey their meanings. In these fields, domestic considerations are given more weight than in the natural sciences, technology, and medical sciences. China’s humanities and social sciences are thus confronted with an unprecedented context: the international knowledge network has divided nations into centre, semi-centre and periphery (Altbach 1998 ); its function has been substantially strengthened by the exponential growth of the Internet, and by the fact that English has become a language (Crystal 1997 ; Watson 2000 ; Yang 2001 ). It is both difficult and necessary (even urgent) for China to raise the level of internationalisation of its humanities and social sciences research, due to the fact that the mainstream knowledge today is Western. Even when one writes about her/his own society, the frame of reference is the dominant (Western) literature. Lacking a sufficient understanding of the dominant discourse would lead to shallow and sometimes meaningless analyses by those in the non-Western world. This issue becomes increasingly relevant as China attracts more academic attention. Therefore, it is preconditioned that Chinese social scientists have already understood the mainstream educational literature well. It is highly necessary to emphasise this direction, because without engaging proactively with the dominant knowledge, the development of non-Western alternatives is almost empty talk (Yang 2011 , pp. 401–402).
In 2008, China produced 3,210 SSCI papers, of which 1,125 had mainland Chinese as the first author. Among the 1,125, Peking University was at the top with 100 papers and Tsinghua the second with 56 (Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China 2009 ).
However, there is resentment and envy on the part of those institutions not selected for top-tier investment. Even among those who were selected, some claim that Peking and Tsinghua effectively monopolise the benefits of greater investment.
Hayhoe characterizes zhizhu (自主) as incorporating a greater sense of social responsibility, and being closer to government, while zhizhi (自治) is more like the Western concept of autonomy, exhibiting a greater degree of independence from government.
Altbach, P. G. (1998). Comparative higher education: Knowledge, the university and development . Hong Kong: Comparative Education Research Centre, University of Hong Kong.
Altbach, P. G. (2004). The costs and benefits of world-class universities. Academe, 90 (1), 20.
Article Google Scholar
Asian Development Bank. (ADB). (2008). Education and skills: Strategies for accelerated development in Asia and the Pacific . Manila: ADB.
Associated Press. (2010). Top universities plan to increase international graduate enrolments . August 30th.
Berdahl, R., Graham, J., & Piper, D. R. (1971). State coordination of higher education . Washington: American Council on Education.
Boyer, E. L. (1990). Scholarship reconsidered: Priorities of the professoriate . Princeton, N.J.: Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.
Cai, Y. P. (1986). Cai Yuanpei Quanji . Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company (in Chinese).
Cai, H. X., & Welch, A. (2010). The Chinese knowledge diaspora in the development of Chinese research universities: A case study of the 111 Project . Washington, DC: World Bank.
Cao, C. (2004). Chinese science and the ‘Nobel Prize Complex’. Minerva, 42 , 151–172.
Chen, S., & Chow, C.-Y. (2010). China’s science prowess questioned. South China Morning Post , 29 September, A6.
Chen, X. Z., & Li, Z. Y. (2007). Strategies control in Chinese research universities: Current state, problems and their causes. Tsinghua Journal of Education, 28 (2), 44–50 (in Chinese).
Cheng, J. S. (2005). A statistical analysis of SSCI publications by major Chinese universities. University Educational Science , 92 (4), 37–39 (in Chinese).
Corsten, H. (1987). Technology transfer from universities to small and medium-sized enterprises—An empirical survey from the standpoint of such enterprises. Technovation, 6 (1), 57–68.
Crystal, D. (1997). English as a global language . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
de Moor, R. A. (1993). Academic freedom and university autonomy: Essentials and limitations in academic freedom and university autonomy . Paris: CEPES, UNESCO.
Donovan, B. (2000). A glimpse of journals in China. Learned Publishing, 13 (2), 128–129.
Etzkowitz, H. (2003). Innovation in innovation: The triple helix of university-industry-government relations. Social Science Information, 42 (3), 293–337.
Gao, Q. (1992). History of Chinese thoughts of higher education . Beijing: People’s Education Press (in Chinese).
Geng, Y. L. (2008). Some comparisons of key subjects among the universities under the Ministry of Education. China Electric Power Education, 13 , 11–12 (in Chinese).
Global Higher Education. (2010). Visualisation of national origins of the World University Ranking Top 100 . Online access http://globalhighered.files.wordpress.com/2010/09/manyeyesthetop1002.jpg .
Graduate School of Education, Shanghai Jiao Tong University. (2010). Academic Ranking of World Universities . Online access http://www.arwu.org/ARWU2010.jsp .
Green, M. F., & Hayward, F. M. (1997). Force for change. In M. F. Green (Ed.), Transforming higher education: Views from leaders around the world (pp. 1–27). Phoenix: Oryx.
Gu, B. L. (2004). Scientific research and technology transfer: Understandings and practices from Tsinghua. Journal of the National Academy of Education Administration, 5 , 51–57 (in Chinese).
Gu, B. L. (2008a). Speech at Tsinghua University 2007 year teaching and research prize-giving ceremony. Online access http://news.tsinghua.edu.cn/new/news.php?id=17724 .
Gu, B. L. (2008b). Innovation: A way to success for the research university. Tsinghua Journal of Education , 29 (1), 1–5 (in Chinese).
Hayhoe, R. (1996). China’s universities, 1895–1995: A century of cultural conflicts . New York: Garland.
Book Google Scholar
Hu, P., Wang, Y., & Ma, J. (2006). Reflections on Tsinghua University’s international collaboration. Impact of Science on Society, 3 , 12–16 (in Chinese).
Huisman, J. (2008). World-class universities. Higher Education Policy, 21 , 1–4.
Husén, T. (1994). The idea of the university: Changing roles, current crisis and future challenges. In T. Husén (Ed.), The role of the university: A global perspective (pp. 7–13). Tokyo: United Nations University.
Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China. (2009). Statistical data of Chinese S&T papers 2009 . Beijing: Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China.
Jacques, M. (2009). When China rules the world: The rise of the middle kingdom and the end of the western world . London: Allen Lane.
Jin, W. (2008). Another good year. Online access http://news.tsinghua.edu.cn/new/news.php?id=17896 .
Jones, H. (2010, 10 September). Economy of brawn and brain. China Daily . Online access http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/bizchina/2010-09/10/content_11286899.htm .
K. T. Li Foundation for the Development of Science and Technology. (2007). Technology transfer in the mainland China higher education institutions . Taipei: K. T. Li Foundation for the Development of Science and Technology (in Chinese).
Levin, R. (2010). The rise of Asia’s universities? Foreign Affairs (May/June).
Li, S. M. (2007). Research performance of higher education institutions in Beijing, Shanghai, Hong Kong and Taipei, 1994–2005: Analysis of SCI and SSCI data. Tsinghua Journal of Education , 28 (2), 90–97 (in Chinese).
Li, J. Y., & Hu, R. Y. (1998). Is science and technology advancement the key element to the transformation of economic growth pattern in China? Technoeconomics and Management Research , 39 (2), 39–40 (in Chinese).
Liu, H., & Jiang, Y. Z. (2001). Technology transfer from higher education institutions to industry in China: Nature and implications. Technovation, 21 (3), 175–188.
Liu, N. C., Wang, Q., & Salmi, J. (2011). Paths to a world-class university: Lessons from practices and experiences . Rotterdam, Boston: Sense Publishers.
Liyanage, S., & Mitchell, H. (1994). Strategic management of interactions at the academic-industry interface. Technovation, 14 (10), 641–655.
Maassen, P., & van Vught, F. (1994). Alternative models of governmental steering in higher education: An analysis of steering models and policy-instruments in five countries. In L. Goedegebuure & F. van Vught (Eds.), Comparative policy studies in higher education (pp. 35–65). Utrecht: LEMMA.
MacBryde, J. (1997). Commercialisation of university technology: A case in robotics. Technovation, 17 (1), 39–46.
Marginson, S. (2006). Dynamics of national and global competition in higher education. Higher Education, 52 (1), 1–39.
Marginson, S. (2008, 17 August). China: Rise of research in the Middle Kingdom. Online access http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20080814152535508 .
Marginson, S. (2011). Higher education in East Asia and Singapore: Rise of the Confucian Model. Higher Education, 61 , 587–611.
Mei, M. (2004). Stressing innovation to run a first-class university science park. China Higher Education, 22 , 21–22 (in Chinese).
Mian, S. A. (1994). US university-sponsored technology incubators: An overview of management, policies and performance. Technovation, 14 (8), 525–528.
Ministry of Education. (2010). Outline of the national medium-and long-term program for education reform and development 2010–2020 . Beijing: Ministry of Education.
Mohrman, K. (2008). The emerging global model with Chinese characteristics. Higher Education Policy, 21 , 29–48.
Mohrman, K., Ma, W. H., & Baker, D. (2008). The research university in transition: The emerging global model. Higher Education Policy, 21 , 5–27.
Moore, M. (2010, 25 January). China to lead world scientific research by 2020. Online access http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/7075698/C .
Ordorika, I. (2003). The limits of university autonomy: Power and politics at the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México. Higher Education, 46 (3), 361–388.
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. (OECD). (2008). Reviews of innovation policy: China . OECD: Paris.
Pan, S. Y. (2007). Intertwining of academia and officialdom and university autonomy: Experience from Tsinghua University in China. Higher Education Policy, 20 , 121–144.
Parker, D. D., & Zilberman, D. (1993). University technology transfer: Impacts on local and US economies. Contemporary Policy Issues, 11 (2), 87–96.
Pei, M. X. (2007, October). Corruption threatens China’s future. Policy Brief 55 . Washington, DC: Carnegie Foundation for International Peace.
Pendlebury, D. (2009). Performance measures and the rise of Asia. International Higher Education, 59 , 6–7.
Ricci, M. (1953). China in the sixteenth century: The journals of Mathew Ricci: 1583–1610 . New York: Random House, Inc.
Rogers, E. M., Hall, B. J., Hashimoto, M., & Steffensen, M. (1999). Technology transfer from university-based research centres: The University of New Mexico experience. Journal of Higher Education, 70 (6), 687–705.
Ross, H., Luo, Y., & Cen, Y. H. (2008). Assessing Tsinghua University and US universities on learning process indicators: An approach of higher education quality. Tsinghua Journal of Education , 29 (2), 36–42 (in Chinese).
Salmi, J. (2009). The challenge of establishing world-class universities . Washington, DC: World Bank.
Salmi, J. (2010). Nine common errors when building a new world-class university. Inside Higher Education . Online access http://www.insidehighered.com/blogs/the_world_view/nine_common_errors_when_building_a_new_world_class_university .
Shi, J. H. (2008). The basis and trend of undergraduate teaching in Chinese research universities. Modern University Education, 1 , 62–68 (in Chinese).
Tsinghua Graduate School. (2009). Graduate education in 2009. Online access http://yjsy.cic.tsinghua.edu.cn/docinfo_out/ .
Tsinghua University. (2010). History of Tsinghua University. Online access http://www.tsinghua.edu.cn/eng/board1/boardlist2.jsp?boadid=32&bid2=3203&pageno=1 .
Tunnermann, C. (1996). A new vision of higher education. Higher Education Policy, 9 (1), 11–27.
Wang, D. Z. (2002). Construction of university academic disciplines and the adjustment of programs: Some practices and experience. Chinese University Teaching, 11 , 7–9 (in Chinese).
Wang, X. Y., Yang, X. H., & Wu, Y. F. (2005). Analysis and reform on R&D of Tsinghua University published in recent years. R&D Management , 17 (5), 135–139 (in Chinese).
Watson, K. (2000). Globalisation, educational reform and language policy in transitional societies. In T. Mebrahtu, M. Crossley, & D. Johnson (Eds.), Globalisation, educational transformation and societies in transition (pp. 41–68). Oxford: Symposium Books.
Welch, A. (2005). Challenge and change. The academic profession in uncertain times. In A. Welch (Ed.), The professoriate: Profile of a profession (pp. 1–20). Amsterdam: Springer.
Welch, A., & Cai, H.-C. (2010). Enter the dragon: The internationalisation of China’s higher education system. In J. Ryan (Ed.), China’s higher education reform and internationalisation . London: Routledge.
World Bank. (2007). Towards a competitive higher education system in a global economy . Washington, DC: World Bank.
Wu, M. S. (2002). Teaching reforms at Tsinghua: Explorations and practices. Chinese University Teaching, 4 , 16–19 (in Chinese).
Wu, Y. S. (2007). SCI: A mirror to show the status quo of China’s science and technology developments. Online access http://news.tsinghua.edu.cn/new/news.php?id=16703 .
Xie, W. H. (2006). The construction and research of social sciences and the humanities at Tsinghua: Retrospect and reflections. Online access http://news.tsinghua.edu.cn/new/news.php?id=14276 .
Yang, R. (2001). An obstacle or a useful tool? The role of the English language in internationalising Chinese universities. Journal of Studies in International Education, 5 (3), 339–356.
Yang, R. (2005). Corruption in China’s higher education system: A malignant tumour. International Higher Education, 39 , 18–20.
Yang, G. G. (2008, 27 June). Tsinghua targets national strategic needs. China Education Daily , 1 (in Chinese).
Yang, R. (2009). Enter the dragon? China’s higher education returns to the wold community: The case of the Peking University personnel reforms. In J. C. Smart (Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (pp. 427–461). Dordrecht: Springer.
Chapter Google Scholar
Yang, R. (2011). Educational research in Confucian cultural contexts: Reflections on methodology. Comparative Education, 47 (3), 395–405.
Yang, R., & Welch, A. (2010). Globalisation, transnational academic mobility and the Chinese knowledge diaspora: The case of Melbourne University. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 31 (5), 593–607.
Zhou, X. N. (2008). Tsinghua University 2007 conference to award research and teaching achievements. Online access http://edu.people.com.cn/GB/7135728.html .
Authors and affiliations.
Faculty of Education, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China
Faculty of Education and Social Work, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Correspondence to Anthony Welch .
Rights and permissions
Reprints and Permissions
About this article
Cite this article.
Yang, R., Welch, A. A world-class university in China? The case of Tsinghua. High Educ 63 , 645–666 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-011-9465-4
Published : 22 July 2011
Issue Date : May 2012
DOI : https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-011-9465-4
Share this article
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
- Higher education
- Tsinghua University
- World-class universities
- Find a journal
- Publish with us