Article Critique
Our activity
Finished orders
Professional writers
Writers online now
Operators are online
Of 5 average writers' score
What is a Critique?
To start us off, it is important for us to ask ourselves, “What is a critique?” Article critiques can be referred to as objective types of analysis of scientific or literary pieces. In these analyses, there is usually some emphasis that is laid on whether the writer supports the article`s main points or not. It is important to note that this emphasis is done based on relevant and reasonable arguments that are founded on facts.
At times, there is a tendency for people to become derailed and find them merely making summary points of articles without challenging and analyzing them. This is something that should be done away with because you will not have answered the question of, “What is a critique?” A valid critique essay is meant to demonstrate a person’s impression of a particular article. This should be done while concurrently providing enough evidence to reinforce these impressions.
When you are taking the position of a critic, you should take your time to scrutinize and read through the article and article review example thoughtfully and carefully. Once you have done this, you should then move to preparing your evidence and arguments cogently and vividly.
Reading Actively
1) read the article at least once to get its main idea.
You should ensure that the first time you go through an article and an article critique example, the overall argument which is being relayed by the author should get inscribed in your mind. It is also essential to make sure that you pay keen interest to the article`s thesis because this is the backbone of the answer to the question of “how to write an article critique.”
Check Our Samples
Argumentative Essay
New Technology: Beneficial or Dangerous?
Academic level: Bachelor
Subject: Communication
Paper format: MLA
Corporate Social Responsibility
Subject: Management
Paper format: Harvard
Master’s Prepared Nurse Interview
Academic level: Master
Paper format: APA
Research Paper
The Maya Tribe
Academic level: Undergraduate
Subject: History
2) Re-read the Article as You Mark It Up
Take some time to reread the article, but this time; make sure you use tools such as a highlighter or even a red pen to create conspicuous markings. For you to perform this task efficiently, you could read through the article while asking yourself questions such as:
- What is this article`s target audience?
- What argument is the author trying to bring to light?
- What purpose does the author have in arguing such a thesis?
- Is it possible to find blank spaces in the author`s argument?
3) Create Legends for the Markings That You Make
Creating legends for your markings entails coming up with unique symbols that enable you to tell the difference between the parts of the article that you have found inconsistent, confusing or essential. A good example is the use of circles to indicate obscure passages, stars to show inconsistencies and underlining to show essential passages. These are some of the skills that will set you apart from your contemporaries when you`re learning how to critique a research article.
4) Come Up With Preliminary Concepts for Your Critique
Always ensure that you craft a rough opinion of the article that you have at hand. Scrutinize the overall arguments that the author relays after reading the article around three or four times and record your reactions in the text.
After you have done this, come up with a list of the possible evidence sources that you will use in your critique. Try to recall any piece of literature that you might have read, perused through or even documentaries that you think are relevant in assisting you to evaluate the article review example.
How to Critique an Article: Gathering Evidence
Question if the writer`s general message is reasonable.
Make sure that you test the author`s hypothesis and go a step further to compare it with similar examples. While doing this, analyze the writer`s main message to find its application in the real world and practicality regardless of whether the author has done in-depth research as well as quoted highly-esteemed experts. In addition to this, examine the article`s conclusion and introduction so as to ensure that they can pass off as convincing, corresponding elements.
Search through the Article to Check for Biases
In case the author has something to profit from the various conclusions and points that are depicted in the piece, then there is a possibility of bias being demonstrated. The leading indicators of bias include the ignoring of contrary evidence and misappropriating evidence, and are the biggest enemy to a writer that is learning how to critique a research article. All these things are done by authors in a bid to make their conclusions to come off different from the way they are, while also imparting their own foundation-less opinions in the article.
It is important to note that bias can be derived from a narrow point of view. Be keen to flesh out preferences that are linked to gender, race, politics, class, and ethnicity, and you’ll have begun your journey into mastering how to critique an article.
You Shouldn`t Ignore Stylistic Elements
The article`s content is highly likely to be the most vital aspect of your literary critique, but take care not to overlook the literary and formal techniques which are used by the author. Pay keen attention to vague choices of words as well as the writer`s tone in the article. This comes in handy, moreso when dealing with the non-scientific type of materials.
These stylistic aspects of a particular article can function to reveal deeper problems found in the argument. A good example can be seen in articles that are written in overzealous and heated tones. When you scrutinize them further in your process of how to critique an article , you shouldn`t be shocked to find the author having a knack to reject contradictory evidence during analysis.
Formatting Your Article Critique
1) start with a great introduction that gives an outline of your argument.
When starting off your article format, you shouldn`t write an introduction that exceeds two paragraphs and ensures, within these two paragraphs, your critique’s basic framework has been laid out vividly. Begin by noting the areas where the article in your critique succeeds or fails most remarkably while giving reasons to support your stand.
It is essential for you to remember to include the author`s name, a statement regarding the thesis and article`s focus, the journal and article`s title, its publication date in the article critique introductory paragraph. Also, note the main academic writing style that’s commonly incorporated is APA format article critiques unless your professor tells you otherwise.
2) In Your Article Critique`s Body, Give Evidence To Reinforce Your Argument
All the paragraphs in your critique essay body should talk about new ideas or better still, expand your points further and in a new direction. Start all the body paragraphs with topic sentences that help to summarize the paragraph`s content readers should expect to come. You should, however, not feel as though your article format requires you to fit the whole paragraph into a topic sentence. This is a place in many article critique examples people use to make transitions into new and different ideas.
3) Wrap up Your Critique by Making a Summary of Your Argument and Giving Potential Implications
It is vital for you to recap your APA format article critique`s main points while also explaining to the readers the relevance of your review to the entire discipline as a whole. This will assist readers to understand that your work has broader implications to that particular field of study and not merely attempting to debunk another scholar`s messy work. Lastly, you should strive to see to it that you have left a permanent mark on your readers in your article`s conclusion via the use of specific language to show your work`s importance.
With these simple steps, you will have unraveled the puzzle of how to write a critique for an article.
AssignmentHolic
UK Writing Service
How to Write an Article Critique
In this article, we show you how to write an article critique. The same rules apply for how to critique a journal article and how to critique a research article. The structure and layout of your article critique are easy, it is the actual critique content that is tricky. You have to find a way of determining what is good and what is bad, all while ensuring you understand what was written intentionally by the writer, and what is a glaring mistake. And, when you need to get assignment help , feel free to contact us.
You may point out how the writer missed the point of the research data, or maybe misinterpreted the research data. Ideally, you need to keep your bias out of the paper, but you will be adding your own opinion at some point, so your job is to make sure your bias is as balanced as possible.
How to Critique an Article – The Preamble
Your professor or education institution will specify what comes first. Most will ask for a title page and explain what needs to be featured on it. Some may want a contents page, abstract, and so forth. Your college will have its own rules on settings, layout, format, style, and how you must submit your work.
Introduction
You will need to list the name of the authors, and you will need to enter the title of the article. You may have to give the main point of the article you are critiquing, and you may have to provide a thesis statement that acts as a preview to your analysis.
If you are figuring out how to critique a research article, the main point of the paper is usually written in its title and in its thesis statement. For example, if it is called, “The movement of snails in urban areas,” then that alone will require only a slight amount of elaboration when you write your introduction. For example, you may elaborate and explain where the evidence was gathered and in which time frame and time period it was gathered.
In keeping with the snail example, your thesis may be that the paper is too short-sighted because it draws its conclusions from limited studies and the studies didn’t account for changes in seasonal weather.
You now discuss the main points of the article, and you are able to flesh out those points a little more than you were able to in your introduction. Maybe discuss the major points and the minor points. If there are any arguments in the paper, then you may summarize and discuss them. You should also summarize and discuss the findings in the article. Remember that you are not critiquing them or judging them at this point, you are merely pointing them out for the benefit of the reader.
As a side note, if you are in full-time education, then you are also showing your professor that you understood and recognized the points made in the article. It also shows the depth at which you understood the text. For example, in the movie “Maleficent,” most movie critics explain how the protagonist lost her wings, became ugly, and was shunned and considered evil. However, those who understood the movie on a deeper level could link her losing her wings with a woman losing her breast after a cancer scare, and how she feels ugly and shunned in the same way as Maleficent. The summary is a good place to show your professor that you understood the text on every level.
The Critique
When most people think about how to critique an article, they think about discussing its strengths and weaknesses, and that is a good place to start, but you need to critique the text and its writer. For example, you can critique the point being made by the writer, and you may also critique the way in which the writer made the point.
For example, the professionals at the Assignment Writing Service UK know how to critique a journal article and its author. A writer may have made a point in a research paper about how the data shows that immunizations do not cause autism but may also point out that the writer never really examined the original text and is relying too heavily on the refuting evidence rather than concentrating on the weakness of the original text. The writers at the AssignmentHolic Service know how to get under the skin of an issue in order to pull out points that most students are not experienced enough to notice.
You are allowed to give your opinions, but they need to be clear and finite. Try to back them with evidence, even though it can be tough to find reliable evidence and try to back up your opinions with examples. For example, if you say that the writing is childlike in nature, then cite a few passages that you consider childlike and explain why you think they are childlike.
When students learn how to critique an article, they often struggle with the conclusion because they do not fully understand what a conclusion is or does. The point of a critique conclusion is not to recap what you wrote. The point is to look back at your original thesis in the introduction and explain how you have proven it, disproven it, or how the thesis is still unresolved. You may summarize the key points you made, but only in an effort to prove or disprove your thesis. Close your critique with a statement about the research that is still needed in the field, and maybe a comment about the significance of the research.
What’s an Article Critique and How to Write It
What is an article critique assignment.
An article critique, also known as a response paper, is a formal evaluation of a journal article or another type of literary or scientific content. Your main goal is to show whether or not the author provided reasonable arguments and facts for their main points.
How to Write an Article Critique
Although the concept is fairly simple, many students still end up wondering: “What is a research article critique?” After the initial explanation, the professor doesn’t provide many additional instructions. So you simply assume that you’ll need to read a research article and then discuss it from a critical point of view or you can use the help of professional writer from the best essay writing service . That assumption is correct. However, the article critique is a much more complex challenge than most students expect.
- Instead of simply summarizing the main points of the article, you must critique them. This is where most students make a mistake; they offer a mere summary of the research article they read. Journal articles already have summaries. Your professor doesn’t want to get that. They want your unique opinion and discussion.
- You should provide not only your impressions of the article, but evidence that backs them up as well.
- In addition to identifying the main idea of the article, you should also clarify its background and purpose.
- Most of all, you’ll focus on the issues this article raises, as well as the ones it avoids.
Now that we elaborated on that definition, let’s get to the main point: how to critique an article. We’ll give you specific steps to follow, so you’ll complete this paper with success.
Step 1: Active Reading
You cannot critique a research article before you read and understand it. These journal articles can be quite lengthy, and they often involve terms you don’t understand. That’s why simple reading won’t be enough. You’ll have to engage in active and close reading , accompanied with some research, so you can define and understand the terms that are new to you.
During this process, you will observe facts and details about the text. You will identify the main point of the author, as well as the arguments they used to support that point.
This means that you’ll definitely need a marker, as well as a note-taking app. If you prefer taking notes the old-fashion way, get a notebook and start writing as you read.
Make sure to identify these main aspects of the research as you read through the article:
- Research problem and research goal
- Research methods
- Participants in the research
- Main findings
- Conclusions
You’ll probably need to read the article several times before you’re done with this stage. You’ll discover new layers with each reading, and new ideas on how to critique will come to your mind. Take notes of those ideas, too.
Speaking of notes, don’t make them brief. Maybe you think that a brief note expresses your entire idea, but it doesn’t. Remember: this is a complex type of academic paper. You’re analyzing an advanced text, so it’s easy to forget some of your ideas when the time to write comes. Yes; it will take more time for you to read and take notes of your observations. However, you’ll minimize the obstacles during the writing process if you’re willing to make this effort.
Step 2: Develop a Preliminary Outline
Now that you have thorough understanding of the article and you took plenty of notes, it’s time to organize them into a preliminary outline. Why is this a preliminary outline ? – Because you’re still not done with the process of critique. In this outline, you’ll just plan how you’ll discuss the main points of the article.
Step 3: Question the Author’s Main Points
This is the first thing the professor will wonder when they start reading your critique: “Did this student understand the difference between a summary and an analysis? The article critique is not a summary; it’s an analysis from a critical point of view. Although your main purpose is not persuasion, you still have to develop a convincing discussion.
To achieve that, you must wonder whether or not the writer’s overall message is logical. This goal will demand additional research. You hardly have the entire base of knowledge needed for analyzing a researcher’s work. Thus, you’ll have to search for similar examples and compare this article’s hypothesis with them.
You can check the logic of the message in an easy way: compare the introduction and the conclusion. Do the elements of these two sections match?
In addition to the main message and the logic of the article, you’ll question other aspects, too:
- The research methods
- The results
- The discussion
- The stylistic elements
Yes; even the stylistic elements are important. If the author’s style is incomprehensive, you may use that argument as an element of your critique.
When you’re questioning the main elements and points of the article, remember: you’re not obliged to write a negative critique. The critique can be positive as well. If you agree with all points, you’ll write a positive critique. If you don’t agree, you’ll write your remarks. If you’re somewhere in between (that’s the usual approach of article critiques), you’ll emphasize both the positive and negative elements of the article. In any case, you must use strong arguments to support your points.
Step 4: Identify Contradictions
Throughout the reading, maybe you identified some contradictions in the article. Researchers, whether intentionally or unintentionally, can be biased. Thus, they may ignore contrary evidence or even misinterpret it, so they will turn it to their advantage.
This bias can come from prejudices. An architect with traditional education, for example, has prejudices towards feng shui, and they will ignore some evidence that might prove the benefits of that method. A medical expert will have prejudices towards Chinese medicine. You get the point.
Note any biases, and you’ll find the contradictions. Whenever the author mentions another author’s work, check out that source. Yes; it will require more reading, but it will help you identify the weak points in the article, so you’ll be able to critique it.
If the author cited untrustworthy evidence, you may add that point in your critique.
Step 5: Write It!
You’ll have plenty of notes by this stage. Don’t worry; that’s a good thing. All you need to do is organize them in a clear outline, so you’ll know what logical progression to follow as you discuss the article. Once you’re ready, you may start with the writing process.
- Disclose Your Main Argument in the Introduction
It’s not that hard to start writing the introduction. You should provide the title of the article you’re critiquing, its author’s name, the journal where it was published, and the publication date. Then, you’ll make a statement about the focus of this research article. It has a thesis statement, right? Include it in the introduction.
Most types of academic papers contain a thesis statement in the introduction. In the article critique, the introduction should also outline your main argument. Disclose your main points of critique in this statement, so it will give the reader an idea of what they are about to read.
- Write the Body Paragraphs
Now, the time for a real critique starts. Each one of the body paragraphs should expand on a new point of the article. Since this is not a 5-paragraph essay (the article critique will be much longer!), you may use subheadings for these sections. If you’re writing a brief article critique, you don’t have to do that.
Each paragraph of the body should start with a topic sentence, which you’ll develop further in the paragraph. Make sure there’s a logical connection between these parts of the paper.
- Summarize Your Arguments
In the conclusion, you’ll summarize your critique and you’ll suggest its potential implications. You may recommend further research, which will shed new light on the issue and will improve the work of the writer you just critiqued.
Step 6: Revise!
Do not skip this step! Don’t even think about it. The article critique is a serious project, which should showcase your capacity of critical thinking and argumentation. If you fail to revise it, even the slightest flaw will ruin the impression for the reader.
During this process, pay attention to the citations. Did you reference all sources properly? Proofread the bibliography, too! If you don’t know how to format it, make sure to follow the rules of article critique APA formatting style.
This is not a simple project. In fact, the article critique may be one of the most complex academic writing challenges for students. However, it’s also very important. It teaches you how to use the work of another writer without being completely convinced in their point of view. It teaches you how to question and check their arguments.
You’re developing the skill of critical thinking, which is extremely important for your progress in any career. So pay attention to this assignment; the results are well worth the effort.
We can help you with:
- Research Paper
Why choose us
People talk about us
Believe it or not, but I'm fully satisfied with the essay you've written for me. I have got an excellent mark and I'm now convinced in the truth of your promises. Thanks!
Unbelievable. The writer followed all my instructions and created a brilliant essay, I would say. What I like most of all, no one suspects even that my essay wasn't written by me. Thanks.
How it works
We use cookies. What does it mean? OK
- How to Cite
- Language & Lit
- Rhyme & Rhythm
- The Rewrite
- Search Glass
How to Write an Article Critique
An article critique is an analysis of an article that evaluates the success of a work. Critiques give additional insight into an articles strengths and weaknesses, as well as provide an analysis of its main points. Some formatting styles, such as APA have specific guidelines on how to write a critique however, the necessary components of a critique are generally the same. To adequately critique an article you must have a thorough knowledge of what it is you are critiquing.
Preparation
Read the article. Try not to make any notes when you read the article for the first time.
Read the article again, paying close attention to the main point or thesis of the article and the supporting points that the article uses.
Read the article again. To write a thorough article critique you must have thorough knowledge of the article. Reading it more than once helps to ensure that you haven't missed any important details.
Consider the credentials of the author. Does the author of the article have the necessary credentials to be considered a reliable authorial voice? It is important to consider the author's expertise and possible biases that may be tied to his perspective.
Consider the credentials of the sources used in the article. Are the sources used to support the author's claims authentic and respectable? Published works such as books, journals and other scholarly sources are a few of the adequate sources of information that an author may source.
Writing the Critique
Compose an introduction. According to the University of Waterloo's guide, "How to Write a Critique," the introduction should include the author's name, the name of the article, its source and the thesis or main point of the article.
Summarize the article's supporting points. "How to Write a Critique" suggests that you "summarize the author's purpose and main points/evidence cited that are used for back up."
Determine whether or not the supporting points provided hold up the article's main points adequately and compile your evaluation and review of the article. The University of Waterloo's guide, "How to Write a Critique," recommends that your evaluation contain the answers to the following questions: What are the author's credentials or areas of expertise? Do you agree with the author? Did the author use appropriate methods to gather the evidence? Was the evidence used by the author accurate? Are the article and the evidence still valid or are they outdated, leading to an invalid conclusion? Was the author successful in making his/her point?. The University of Waterloo's website also advises that you "divide the article into sections of thought and write a brief summary of each thought in your own words...[and] back up your decisions by stating your reasons."
Write your conclusion. According to "How to Write a Critique," your conclusion should contain a general opinion of the article, state your agreement or disagreement with the author and the reasons for your conclusion.
- Check the guidelines for the formatting style you have chosen and shape your article accordingly.
Things You'll Need
- University of Waterloo: How to Write a Critique
Born in Kingston, Jamaica, Chanelle Sicard completed her B.A. in honors English from McMaster University at the age of 20. Sicard has been writing professionally since November 2008, has a chapter published in "Universal Healthcare Problems in the United States of America," and has written for Poshglam.com, SweetSpot.ca Inc., and "Broadway Magazine."
- Types of Papers
- Article Review
- How To Write A Critique Paper
How to Write a Critique Paper
Critique papers summarize and judge the book, journal article, and artwork, among other sources. Basically, these papers include a critical evaluation of the item under reflection. In this case, learners must follow an academic writing style and include different sections, like the introduction, body, and conclusion. Moreover, creating a strong thesis statement in critique essays determine the focus of the entire work. In turn, the body section must summarize and evaluate the source objectively. Besides, one must avoid biased judgment during the assessment. The closing paragraph makes an informed summary of the main points and arguments. Hence, one may use recommend ways on how to write a critique paper to improve the work under evaluation.
General Rules on How to Write a Critique Paper
Critique essays contain summaries of the book, journal article , and artworks, among other sources. In particular, critiques use formal rules for academic writing . Students engage in a critical evaluation of the item under consideration. Then, compulsory sections include the introduction, body, and conclusion. In turn, a persuasive thesis statement at the beginning communicates the primary focus of the written work. Further on, the body section summarizes and appraises the source by considering how to write a critique paper. Avoiding biased judgment during the assessment improves the quality of the composition. As a result, the conclusion brings closure to work and connects to the central claim. However, one may restate the thesis and provide practical recommendations.
Definition of a Critique Paper
Critique papers contain a summary and a critical analysis of a source or concept. Basically, these papers lead to a careful analysis of a variety of works like:
- Research Papers – published journal articles, scientific reports, and general reviews
- Media – news reports and periodicals
- Creative Works – paintings, poems, songs, and novels
Critiques use formal and academic writing styles . For instance, students follow a clear structure to present ideas. In practice, critique papers must have the introduction, body, and conclusion. Besides, the body paragraphs contain an evaluation that gauges the usefulness or impact of work under evaluation.
What is more for how to write a critique paper, these rules help to develop:
- covering knowledge of the subject or object under review;
- having a deeper understanding of related works;
- including an appreciation of work’s purposes under analysis;
- recognizing the intended audience and advancement of a central argument in critique essays ;
- considerating how the book, journal article, or artwork relates to the broader issue or context.
Criteria for Writing Critique Papers
There are several criteria on how to write a critique paper that learners can use, depending on primary objectives. Basically, one may use the following standards:
Students evaluate the appropriateness of an item to the audience. For instance, outstanding critique papers show the weaknesses and strengths of the article or the object under evaluation. Besides, they contain ways to improve the source and fit the readers’ needs discussed in critique essays.
Information
Critique essays examine the usefulness of the material under analysis. In particular, one considers if the information makes sense to the audience or contributes to existing knowledge. This process on how to write a critique paper helps to determine if the information expresses the intended meaning.
Learners examine if specific information makes sense to readers. Possible factors to consider may include conceivable jumps in logic, among other weaknesses. As a result, this criterion determines the overall quality of a piece of work under review.
Critique essays may focus on the balance between facts and fiction. Basically, the criterion applies where two sides of an argument exist. In this case, students determine the vagueness of the information presented when organizing critique papers.
7 Steps on How to Write Critique Papers
1. understanding the task.
Before starting the writing process, students must understand the work under discussion for writing critique papers. The following steps lead to better results:
- studying the work under consideration;
- making notes on relevant sections of the critique papers;
- appreciating the main argument and the purpose of the object or work;
- considering how the work relates to a broader issue or context.
2. Writing an Introduction
One must write a short introduction. In this case, the opening paragraph should be approximately 10% of the overall word length of a critique paper. Hence, the introductory part should:
- identify the work under review, the date of formation and author or creator;
- explain the context of the work under evaluation – the required information may include social or political context and place of work in an academic tradition;
- have a thesis statement that indicates the type of evaluation used.
Students must summarize the main points objectively. In particular, the process includes stating how authors portray original messages using characters, ciphers, media, or styles, covering how to write a critique paper. In practice, summaries should be shorter than evaluation parts of critique essays.
4. Critical Evaluation
Critical evaluation gives a detailed appraisal of various elements of critique essays. In this case, students determine the inventor’s effectiveness in achieving the core purpose. As a result, the practical analysis must:
- deconstruct the work;
- identify the strengths and weaknesses;
- examine the success of the source in achieving the primary purpose.
5. Conclusion
The closing paragraphs contain a summary of the overall evaluation of the work. Basically, one should include:
- key reasons identified during the assessment process;
- purpose of the evaluation;
- recommendations for improving the whole work.
6. Reference list
The reference list in critique essays contains cited credible sources . In turn, students should confirm the required referencing style to meet the rules on how to write a critique paper.
7. Proofreading
Revising critique papers helps to identify major grammatical mistakes. In this case, taking adequate time to read through the work improves the quality and expected outcomes.
Additional Tips for Writing Critique Papers
This section of critique papers serves as the heart of the analysis. In particular, students should use compelling examples to support the main ideas and arguments. Moreover, the inquiry method used must align with the one mentioned in the thesis statement.
Closing Paragraph
One must seek advice from the instructor on how to close the paper for learning how to write a critique paper. For example, some instructors may require students to restate the thesis statement at the end of critique essays. Effective conclusions:
- link body paragraphs to the introduction;
- do not present new information.
Summing Up on How to Write a Critique Paper
Critique essays summarize books, academic articles , and artworks, among other sources. Basically, students engage in a critical evaluation of the item under consideration if they know how to write a critique paper. In this case, scholars cover an academic writing style and different sections, like the introduction, body, and conclusion. Moroever, a strong thesis statement in the opening chapters guides entire works. Then, the body section includes a summary and appraisal of sources. In turn, one must avoid biased judgment during assessments. Besides, the conclusion brings closure to work and connects to the central claim. Finally, a recommendation to improve the work under evaluation makes written compositions valid.
How to Get a Girlfriend in College
How to Write an Essay on Time Management in College
Useful articles.
College Essay Introduction
10 Reasons Why Everyone Should Go to College
10 Hardest College Classes
Logical Order
Opinion Essay
Essay on The Real Story of Rosa Parks
Essay on What If the Poor Were Part of City Planning
Essay on The Health Benefits of Clowning Around
- EXPLORE Coupons Tech Help Pro Random Article About Us Quizzes Contribute Train Your Brain Game Improve Your English Popular Categories Arts and Entertainment Artwork Books Movies Computers and Electronics Computers Phone Skills Technology Hacks Health Men's Health Mental Health Women's Health Relationships Dating Love Relationship Issues Hobbies and Crafts Crafts Drawing Games Education & Communication Communication Skills Personal Development Studying Personal Care and Style Fashion Hair Care Personal Hygiene Youth Personal Care School Stuff Dating All Categories Arts and Entertainment Finance and Business Home and Garden Relationship Quizzes Cars & Other Vehicles Food and Entertaining Personal Care and Style Sports and Fitness Computers and Electronics Health Pets and Animals Travel Education & Communication Hobbies and Crafts Philosophy and Religion Work World Family Life Holidays and Traditions Relationships Youth
- HELP US Support wikiHow Community Dashboard Write an Article Request a New Article More Ideas...
- EDIT Edit this Article
- PRO Courses Guides New Tech Help Pro Expert Videos About wikiHow Pro Coupons Quizzes Upgrade Sign In
- Browse Articles
- Learn Something New
- Train Your Brain
- Improve Your English
- Explore More
- Support wikiHow
- About wikiHow
- H&M Coupons
- Hotwire Promo Codes
- StubHub Discount Codes
- Ashley Furniture Coupons
- Blue Nile Promo Codes
- NordVPN Coupons
- Samsung Promo Codes
- Chewy Promo Codes
- Ulta Coupons
- Vistaprint Promo Codes
- Shutterfly Promo Codes
- DoorDash Promo Codes
- Office Depot Coupons
- adidas Promo Codes
- Home Depot Coupons
- DSW Coupons
- Bed Bath and Beyond Coupons
- Lowe's Coupons
- Surfshark Coupons
- Nordstrom Coupons
- Walmart Promo Codes
- Dick's Sporting Goods Coupons
- Fanatics Coupons
- Edible Arrangements Coupons
- eBay Coupons
- Log in / Sign up
- Hobbies and Crafts
- Photography
How to Write a Photography Critique
Last Updated: April 8, 2021 References Approved
This article was co-authored by Karen De Jager . Karen De Jager is a Professional Photographer and the Owner of Spectrum Photography LLC, operating in the broader East Bay area based in Pleasant Hill, California. Karen is a published and award-winning photographer who offers both in-studio, outdoor, and on-location sessions specializing in capturing a wide variety of special moments and events in a natural, photojournalistic style. Her ability to look at every photoshoot as an adventure and general passion for delivering excellent customer service led to Spectrum Photography’s recognition by Expertise.com as the “Best Wedding Photographers in Vallejo” in both 2018 and 2020. There are 17 references cited in this article, which can be found at the bottom of the page. wikiHow marks an article as reader-approved once it receives enough positive feedback. In this case, 87% of readers who voted found the article helpful, earning it our reader-approved status. This article has been viewed 195,014 times.
Critiques can guide budding and seasoned artists alike as refine their work. Writing a critique involves evaluating the image's technical and compositional elements. Analyze how the different elements work together and suggest ways for the photographer to improve. Keep your tone agreeable but constructive, and offer advice beyond personal like or dislike of the image. With a little structure and thorough analysis, you can write critiques that help the photographer learn and grow.
Formatting Critiques
- Write your introduction after you've written the body so you know what to summarize.
- Writing your positive thoughts first can make the photographer more open to negative opinions.
- Brevity is necessary, but make sure each sentence is a complete thought. [4] X Research source
Evaluating Technical Components
- Suggest that the photographer experiment with aperture or shutter speed if the exposure seems off.
- Landscape photos often look best in sharp focus. Soft backgrounds with a focal point on the subject works well in portrait photography.
Analyzing Composition
- Visual weight can be improved by introducing contrast, focusing on eye-catching colors, and changing the picture's angle. [11] X Research source
Maintaining a Constructive Tone
- Photographers will listen to negative comments more intently if backed up with commentary.
- Instead of, "I love this duckling picture!," you might say, "The ducklings make a strong focal point, and softening the background allowed their colors to pop."
- Instead of, "Your exposure looked terrible," for example, you could say, "The picture could benefit from a faster shutter speed setting." [17] X Research source
Expert Q&A
- Critique the work, not the artist. Even if you don't get along with the photographer, keep their work separate from who they are as a person. This is especially important if you are a photography instructor. [18] X Research source ⧼thumbs_response⧽ Helpful 0 Not Helpful 0
- Remember: art is subjective. A critique should not be written as an end-of-discussion grade given to the photo. It instead offers a personal perspectives and suggestions for the photographer to improve. ⧼thumbs_response⧽ Helpful 0 Not Helpful 0
- Write down your first impressions and compare ⧼thumbs_response⧽ Helpful 0 Not Helpful 0
You Might Also Like
- ↑ http://www.citewrite.qut.edu.au/write/critique.jsp
- ↑ http://www.creative-writing-now.com/how-to-write-a-critique.html
- ↑ https://www.hws.edu/academics/ctl/pdf/critique.pdf
- ↑ https://grants.nih.gov/grants/policy/review/rev_prep/critiques.htm
- ↑ https://student.unsw.edu.au/structure-critical-review
- ↑ http://clickitupanotch.com/2016/03/how-to-critique-a-photograph/
- ↑ http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/brief-guide-to-critiquing-your-own-photos/
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t3A3SnPFPk0
- ↑ http://www.apogeephoto.com/critiquing-your-photographs/
- ↑ Karen De Jager. Professional Photographer. Expert Interview. 18 March 2021.
- ↑ http://www.ultimate-photo-tips.com/photography-rules-of_composition.html
- ↑ https://expertphotography.com/10-ways-to-critique-a-photo/
- ↑ http://www.the-digital-picture.com/Photography-Tips/backgrounds.aspx
- ↑ http://erickimphotography.com/blog/2012/07/02/how-to-give-a-constructive-critique-in-street-photography/
- ↑ https://photographylife.com/how-to-critique-your-photos-accurately
- ↑ https://psychologyforphotographers.com/a-crash-course-in-the-art-of-constructive-critique
- ↑ https://teaching.temple.edu/sites/tlc/files/resource/pdf/5_Best_Practices_for_Critiques%20%5BAccessible%5D_0.pdf
About This Article
- Send fan mail to authors
Reader Success Stories
Gene Stewart
Dec 29, 2022
Did this article help you?
Douglas Robertson
Jun 11, 2020
Harry Franks
Sep 27, 2016
Sep 15, 2017
Featured Articles
Trending Articles
Watch Articles
- Terms of Use
- Privacy Policy
- Do Not Sell or Share My Info
- Not Selling Info
Get all the best how-tos!
Sign up for wikiHow's weekly email newsletter
IMAGES
COMMENTS
Summary You now discuss the main points of the article, and you are able to flesh out those points a little more than you were able to in your introduction. You should also summarize and discuss the findings in the article
Critique the main points of the given piece, not just summarize them. Get your article critique starting at just C$10.00 per page. To be able to write an article critique you need to possess lots of knowledge and
An article critique, also known as a response paper, is a formal evaluation of a journal article or another type of literary or scientific content
An article critique is an analysis of an article that evaluates the success of a work. Critiques give additional insight into an articles strengths and weaknesses, as well as provide an analysis of its main points
Critique papers summarize and judge the book, journal article, and artwork, among other sources. Critique papers contain a summary and a critical analysis of a source or concept. In practice, critique papers must have the introduction
Writing a critique involves evaluating the image's technical and compositional elements. Outline your critique before you write it. Take notes on your initial thoughts and suggestions while looking at the photograph