If you'd prefer that certain types of cookie are not saved on your browser when visiting our website, use the toggles below to adjust those preferences and click "Save choices".
These cookies are necessary for the website to function and without them you would not be able to reliably use the website. For example, logging into your account or completing forms.
A series of cookies that collect anonymised data on how users interact with our website. This anonymous data helps us improve the website with a focus on its users, for example, ensuring the most popular content is easier to access.
View associated providers +
These cookies track your online activity to help advertisers deliver more relevant and personalised advertising or to limit how many times you see an ad. These cookies can share that information with other organisations or advertisers.
- Teach Early Years
- Teach Primary
- Teach Secondary
- New for Schools
Home > Learning Resources
KS1 and KS2 Maths – Problem solving
- Author: Mike Askew
- Main Subject: CPD
- Subject: Maths
- Date Posted: 20 June 2012
If children use well worn techniques to solve problems without understanding or modelling the context, their maths skills won't fully evolve
Children, from birth, are proficient problem solvers. By the age of two or three they have solved what are probably life’s two biggest problems - how to walk and how to talk. As they get older they solve practical problems, such as sharing a bag of sweets fairly with others, long before they’ve heard of division. In this article, I look at how we can build on this natural propensity to solve problems in teaching mathematics.
Routine and non-routine problems
Routine problems are problems children know how to solve based on their previous experiences. The sort of thinking required by routine problems can be described as reproductive: the child only needs to recall or reproduce a procedure or method they have previously learnt. A problem like ‘Apples’, for example (see below), is likely to be a routine problem for most children at the upper end of primary school; they know to multiply the two numbers together without having to think deeply about what operation to use.
• Apples on a supermarket shelf are in bags of eight. • If Jane buys six bags, how many apples is that?
In contrast, non-routine problems are where the learner does not immediately have a solution tucked under his belt. The problem solver has to put some effort into understanding the problem and creating, rather than recalling, a solution strategy. Non-routine problems engage learners in productive thinking.
We often think of non-routine problems as needing to be unusual or not having, to us as adults, an immediately obvious method of solution. ‘Stamps’ is typical of this type of non-routine problem.
• Clearing out a desk draw I found a collection of 5p and 6p stamps. • I have a parcel to post that needs 58p worth of stamps on it. • Can I create this exactly using the stamps I found? • If so, is there more than one way of doing this?
In choosing problems to work with, we need to decide whether or not we think a problem will be routine or non-routine for the particular children working on it. In the rest of this article, the problems chosen are being treated as though they are non-routine problems for the children working on them. That’s not to say that I don’t think routine problems have a place in the curriculum - they do. Here, however, I want to deal with some of the issues around teaching and learning non-routine problems.
The importance of context
• Four hungry girls share three pizzas equally. • Eight hungry boys share six pizzas equally. • Does each girl get more pizza than each boy, less or the same?
As a routine problem, the ‘story’ of pizzas and hungry children doesn’t serve any real purpose: children quickly learn to disregard the context, to strip out the mathematics and to work some procedure. The problem could just as easily have been put in the context of builders sharing bricks and many learners would happily say each builder would get 3/4 of a brick, without stopping to question the near impossibility of sharing out bricks.
We can, however, treat ‘Pizzas’ as a non-routine problem and use it to introduce children to thinking about fractions and equivalences. The context of hungry children and pizzas then becomes important. It is not chosen simply to be window-dressing for a fraction calculation. Nor are pizzas chosen because children are intrinsically motivated by food, making the unpalatable topic of fractions digestible. No, the context s chosen because children know about fair shares and slicing up pizzas - they can solve this problem without any formal knowledge of fractions. As the researcher Terezhina Nunes once pointed out, young children would not be able to solve the ‘bald’ calculation 3 divided by 4 but, “show me four young children who, given three bars of chocolate to share out fairly, hand the bars back saying ‘it can’t be done.”
Children have ‘action schemas’ for solving problem like ‘Pizzas’ - they can find ways to solve this with objects, pictures, diagrams and, eventually, symbols. Teaching can then build on the children’s informal solutions to draw out the formal mathematics of fractions. From being one of 20 ‘problems’ on a worksheet to complete in a lesson, ‘Pizzas’ can become a ‘rich task’ taking up the best part of a lesson, if children work on it in pairs and carefully selected solutions are then shared with the class.
Creating mathematical models
Part of the productive thinking in working on rich, non-routine problems requires children to create mathematical models, and we can teach to support this.
• At the supermarket Myprice, milk costs £1.08 per litre. • This is 7 pence less per litre than milk costs at Locost. • How much does 5 litres of milk cost at Locost?
What is missing from this approach is attention to setting up an appropriate model of the problem. Ultimately this could be a mental model of the problem context, but it helps initially to encourage children to put something on paper that can be shared and discussed. In problems involving quantities, like ‘Milk’, simple bar diagrams can help children create the appropriate model. These help children examine the relationships between the quantities (as opposed to simply fixing on specific numbers and keywords).
Setting up a diagrammatic model begins with creating a representation of what is known in the situation. In this example, we know milk at Myprice costs £1.08, so a diagram for this would look like:
This provides the basis for talking about what the picture for the price of milk at Locost is going to be. Will the bar be longer or shorter? Where is the bar for the 7 pence to be drawn?
Two different models can be set up and children asked to describe the relationship between the prices at the two supermarkets, to see which diagram fits with the information in the problem. If the diagram for the price at Locost is shorter by 7, then two statements can be made:
MYPRICE £1.08p LOCOST 7p
• Myprice milk costs 7 pence more than milk at Locost.
• Locost milk costs 7 pence less than milk at Myprice.
In comparison, making the bar for milk at Locost longer by 7 gives different comparative statements:
MYPRICE £1.08p 7p LOCOST
• Myprice milk costs 7 pence less than milk at Locost.
• Locost milk costs 7 pence more than milk at Myprice.
Children can then talk about which of these situations fits with the wording in the problem.
Having established that Locost milk must be £1.15 a litre, children can go on to produce the bar diagram model for this.
Supporting non-routine problem solving
Where the problems were played out as non-routine, three factors identified are worth noting. First, in choosing the tasks, the teachers made sure they would build on learners’ prior knowledge - as I suggest a problem like ‘Pizzas’ can. Second, in contrast to focusing on getting the answer, the researchers observed what they called ‘sustained pressure for explanation and meaning’. In other words, the teachers pressed for children to explain what and why they were doing what they were doing rather than simply focusing on whether or not they had got the correct answer. Third, the amount of time children were allowed to work on the problem was neither too long or too short: children need enough time to ‘get into’ a problem, but too much time can lead to a loss of engagement.
Share good practice
Gather together a collection of problems covering all the years of education in your school (or ask teachers to each contribute two or three problems).
Working together in small groups, teachers sort the problems into three groups:
1. Problems they think would be routine for the children they teach 2. Problems they think would be non-routine for their children 3. Problems they think would be much too difficult for their age group
Everyone agrees to try out a problem from group 2 with their class. Discuss how too much focus on getting the answer can reduce the challenge and stress the importance of pressing children to explain their working. At a subsequent meeting, people report back, focusing in particular on strategies they used to keep the problem solving non-routine.
About the author
Mike Askew is Professor of Primary Education at Monash University, Melbourne. Until recently, he was Professor of Mathematics Education at King’s College, University and Director of BEAM.
You may also be interested in...
- Download your free digital copy of the brand new January issue of Teach Primary now
- Teach Primary Awards 2019 Finalists Announced
- Oxford University Press celebrate double victory
- Free resources for teaching film in primary schools
- National Curriculum Key Stage 2 assessments reveal increased attainment in primaries
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.
Tried & Tested
Power Maths – A Child-Centred, ‘Can-Do’ Mastery Teaching Programme for KS1 and KS2
Fit To Dance Schools From Disney On Ice
‘S!ng Sensational’ And ‘A King Is Born’ – Two Fun New Musical Masterpieces That Children Will Love
Product review: Schofield & Sims Fractions, Decimals & Percentages
See all Tried & Tested products
Recommended for you...
Use coaching to turn failures into learning success
How To Use Books To Help Children Cope With Life
Why Boarding School Fiction Feels Comfortably Familiar
Teach coding using an Xbox controller
Follow us on Twitter @teachprimary :
Share teach primary:.
Copyright 2023 Artichoke Media Ltd
Registered in England and Wales No 14769147 | Registered Office Address: Jubilee House, 92 Lincoln Road, Peterborough, PE1 2SN
Trial and Improvement at KS2
Simply 'having a go' is a great way to make a start on a mathematical problem. Whatever happens, you will have learnt more about the situation and can then tweak your approach. These activities all lend themselves to this 'trial and improvement' way of working.
This collection is one of our Primary Curriculum collections - tasks that are grouped by topic.
Zios and Zepts
Age 7 to 11 challenge level.
On the planet Vuv there are two sorts of creatures. The Zios have 3 legs and the Zepts have 7 legs. The great planetary explorer Nico counted 52 legs. How many Zios and how many Zepts were there?
You have two sets of the digits 0-9. Can you arrange these in the five boxes to make four-digit numbers as close to the target numbers as possible?
Area and Perimeter
What can you say about these shapes? This problem challenges you to create shapes with different areas and perimeters.
Can you use the information to find out which cards I have used?
Age 5 to 11 challenge level.
Kate has eight multilink cubes. She has two red ones, two yellow, two green and two blue. She wants to fit them together to make a cube so that each colour shows on each face just once.
Fractions in a Box
The discs for this game are kept in a flat square box with a square hole for each. Use the information to find out how many discs of each colour there are in the box.
Can you make a cycle of pairs that add to make a square number using all the numbers in the box below, once and once only?
In this game for two players, take it in turns to shade one petal, or two petals next to each other. Is it better to go first or second?
Can you see how these factor-multiple chains work? Find the chain which contains the smallest possible numbers. How about the largest possible numbers?
- Register for our mailing list
- Schools directory
- Resources Jobs Schools directory News Search
Maths Problem Solving Booklets
Age range: 11-14
Resource type: Worksheet/Activity
23 August 2022
- Share through email
- Share through twitter
- Share through linkedin
- Share through facebook
- Share through pinterest
Maths problem solving booklets covering a wide range of mathematical problems designed to improve problem solving strategies as well as numeracy and mathematical ability.
Designed to be printed as A5 booklets.
Disclaimer: These are free because the problems are from a wide variety of sources, most of which I have forgotten. I am a maths problem magpie and collect maths problems wherever I find them. All I have done is bundled these ones up to make it convienent.
If you find a problem that is yours and you don’t want it used please comment and I’ll remove it - cheers.
Creative Commons "Sharealike"
Your rating is required to reflect your happiness.
It's good to leave some feedback.
Something went wrong, please try again later.
Great resource to use at KS3
Empty reply does not make any sense for the end user
Just what I have been looking for. Thanks so much!
Good resources. Thanks you!
Thanks for sharing. Really useful booklets.
thank you, great resource
Report this resource to let us know if it violates our terms and conditions. Our customer service team will review your report and will be in touch.
Not quite what you were looking for? Search by keyword to find the right resource:
- Art & Design
- Add or Subtract
- Number Lines
- Tell The Time
- Problem Solving
- Maths Tools
- SATs Past Papers
- Handling Data
Problem Solving KS2 Maths. Have fun solving these Maths problems. Great activities to use Maths problem solving skills in real life scenarios. Links to a selection of printable and interactive Maths resources, great for ks2, ages 8-11 years.
Cycling Timing Challenge Video
Two cycling-mad schoolchildren are taken on a tour of the National Cycling Centre in Manchester. They meet world individual pursuit champion Sarah Storey, and are set a maths challenge related to cycling.
Traditional frog jumping puzzle. Can you swap the green and blue fogs over? How few moves does it take? What if the number of frogs were to change?
Imagine that you're walking along the beach, a rather nice sandy beach with just a few small pebbles in little groups here and there. You start off by collecting just four pebbles and you place them on the sand in the form of a square. The area inside is of course just 1 square something, maybe 1 square metre, 1 square foot, 1 square finger ... whatever.
Problem Solving Task Cards Printable
This resource contains an example of a four-step approach for a problem solving strategy and task cards split into levels. Aimed at Year six pupils. Registration required.
Properties Of Numbers Quiz
By the time they reach Year 5, the third year in KS2, children should be familiar with certain properties of numbers which they have come across in their Maths lessons. They should, for example, know the difference between multiples and factors and should also know what square numbers are. Play this quiz for 9-10 year olds and see what you have remembered.
Word Problems Interactive
Maths word problem generator. Select difficulty and number of questions, check your answers and see how you are doing with the % indicator.
- More Problem Solving links ->
Our sister site, crickweb.co.uk, provides 265 free educational interactive teaching resources and activities for Primary/Elementary Schools, teachers, parents & children. Suitable for use on an IWB, PC or Mac at school and at home.
2007 - 2023 Everyschool.co.uk | All rights reserved | Design by 3913.co.uk